Shopping cart

Your cart is currently empty

Garage Sale

Text of

 

Fair Game's Famous Garage Sale will be returning October 25th-26th!

Our incredibly popular Garage Sale is coming back for the Halloween season! Soon, we will be accepting submissions for our Garage Sale taking place at our Downers Grove location. This is an opportunity to give the lightly used board games from your collection a new home and earn store credit in the process. It is also an opportunity to find an amazing deal on a legion of other used games coming in for the event! More information will be coming soon so stay tuned!
 
 

Sign up for emails!

Update your Preferences!

Seller Resources

See our Seller's Guide!

Interested in selling games at Fair Game’s 2025 Garage Sale? Here’s how it works:

Step 1: Prepare Your Games

  • You may submit up to 15 games per household.
  • Games should be complete and lightly used.
  • If a game has missing components or includes expansions/promos, write the details on an index card and tape it to the box with painter’s tape.
  • Please also use painter’s tape to seal your game boxes shut before drop-off. (This saves everyone time during check-in!) Please include a strip of painters' tape on the front of the game for the pricing label.

Step 2: Submit Your Games Online

  • A Google Form will open Tuesday, October 15, and close Tuesday, October 21.
  • The form will collect your contact info and your game list.
  • All games must be priced at $5 or more.

Step 3: Wait for Submissions to be Processed

  • After submitting, please wait 2 days before dropping off your games.
  • Not sure when you submitted? Call us at 630-963-0640 before heading in.

Step 4: Drop Off Your Games

  • Drop-offs will be accepted Thursday, October 16 – Thursday, October 23 at Fair Game Downers Grove only.
  • At drop-off, we’ll provide stickers for you to attach to your games.
  • No drop-offs after October 23 and no drop-offs at La Grange or Geneva.

Step 5: Payment & Unsold Games

  • If your game sells on Saturday, you’ll earn 80% of the sale price in store credit.
  • On Sunday, all unsold games are automatically discounted by 30%. If sold, then you’ll receive 80% of that discounted price.
  • Unsold games must be picked up by October 31. After that date, they will be donated to local charities and schools.
  • It will take up to 2 weeks for us to process all sales and have store credit applied to your accounts.

Questions? Check out the FAQ below or reach out:

Call: 630-963-0640

Email: [email protected]

FAQ

Can I drop off my games at La Grange or Geneva?

No. All drop-offs must be made at Fair Game Downers Grove. If that’s difficult, consider coordinating with a friend or neighbor.

What items can I sell?

  • Lightly used games priced at $5+.
  • Bundles are limited to a single game + its expansions (e.g., Boss Monster + Next Level).
  • No puzzles, role playing game books, miniatures/miniature games (Warhammer, Warmachine, etc.), or items requiring assembly/painting. If you’re unsure, email us with details.
  • We reserve the right to refuse any item.

How should I price my games?

  • Price them to sell on Saturday. Shoppers come looking for value, not collector pricing.
  • Remember: all unsold games are automatically 30% off on Sunday.

Why do I only receive 80% in store credit?

  • Processing 1,500+ games takes a huge amount of time and resources. The 20% helps offset the costs of running the event.

Can I highlight unique features of my game?

  • Yes! Feel free to tape an index card with notes (custom inserts, upgrades, fun stories, etc.) to the box.

How do I use my store credit?

  • Credit is added directly to your account (no gift cards or paper slips).
  • You can use it on anything: new games, booster packs, event fees, etc.
  • Credit can take up to 2 weeks to be added to your account. We’ll notify you if it’s ready sooner.

What if a purchased game is incomplete?

  • All items are sold AS IS, just like at a traditional garage sale. If pieces are missing, you can usually request replacements directly from the publisher.
  • We do not verify completeness, but will track repeated complaints to limit problem sellers in the future.

Why can’t I sell a game for less than $5?

  • To keep processing efficient, $5 is the minimum price. Bundles (up to 2) are allowed but must be a single game with its expansions only (e.g. Heat + Heavy Rain).

Still have questions?

Call: 630-963-0640

Email: [email protected]

Submissions Closed! See you Soon!